The Fine Print of Cryptocurrency Wallet Security: Custodial vs Non-Custodial
Custodial wallet is a type of cryptocurrency wallet that is managed by a third party, while a non-custodial wallet is one where the user is in full control of their private keys.
Source : https://www.gemini.com/cryptopedia/crypto-wallets-custodial-vs-noncustodial
A custodial wallet is a cryptocurrency wallet where the private keys to the wallet are held by a third party. This third party, known as a custodian, has control over the assets stored in the wallet. An example of a custodial wallet is a centralized exchange wallet, where the exchange holds the private keys to the wallet and has control over the assets stored in it.
Custodial wallets are convenient to use because they allow the user to access their assets from any device with an internet connection. However, they are also considered less secure than non-custodial wallets because the user does not hold the private keys to the wallet and must trust the custodian to secure them. If the custodian is hacked or goes bankrupt, the user may lose access to their assets.
Pros & Cons of custodial wallet
Convenient to use: Custodial wallets allow the user to access their assets from any device with an internet connection.
Easy to set up: Custodial wallets do not require the user to generate or secure their own private keys, making them easy to set up and use.
Good for beginners: Custodial wallets can be a good option for cryptocurrency beginners who are not yet comfortable with managing their own private keys.
Less secure: The user does not hold the private keys to the wallet and must trust the custodian to secure them.
Less control: The user does not have complete control over their assets and must follow the custodian's rules and policies.
Risk of censorship: The custodian may freeze the user's account or restrict access to their assets if they suspect suspicious activity or if required by law enforcement
Non custodial wallet
A non-custodial wallet is a cryptocurrency wallet where the user holds the private keys to the wallet and has complete control over the assets stored in it. The user is responsible for securing the private keys and protecting them from being lost or stolen. An example of a non-custodial wallet is a hardware wallet, where the user holds the private keys on a physical device and has complete control over the assets stored in it.
Non-custodial wallets are considered more secure than custodial wallets because the user has complete control over their assets and private keys. However, they can be more difficult to use because the user is responsible for securing the private keys and backing them up. If the user loses the private keys, they will lose access to their assets
Pros & Cons of non-custodial wallet
Here are some of the main advantages of using a non-custodial wallet:
Security: Because you are in control of your own private keys, the risk of them being stolen or compromised is significantly reduced, as long as you properly safeguard them.
Control: With a non-custodial wallet, you have complete control over your funds and can make transactions without having to go through a third party.
Privacy: Non-custodial wallets do not require personal information or identification, which can be beneficial for those who value their privacy.
Cost: Non-custodial wallets are often free to use, whereas custodial wallets may charge fees for holding and managing your funds.
And some of the main disadvantage:
Responsibility: Because you are in control of your own private keys, it is crucial that you keep them safe and secure. If you lose or forget your private keys, you will permanently lose access to your funds.
Complexity: Some people may find non-custodial wallets difficult to set up and use, especially if they are not familiar with the concept of private keys.
Compatibility: Not all cryptocurrency exchanges and platforms support non-custodial wallets, so you may have to use a custodial wallet in some situations.
Risk: If you don't have technical knowledge, it's very difficult for a normal person to properly safeguard their private keys, and the risk of loss or theft increases.
Your Cryptocurrency, Your Responsibility: Protecting Your Digital Assets
The security of a custodial or non-custodial wallet depends on a number of factors, and it's hard to make a definitive statement about which is more secure without considering the specific details of each case.
Custodial wallets, which are controlled by a third party, may have better security measures in place to protect your funds, such as multi-sig technology and hardware security modules. However, custodial wallets also come with the risk that the third party may be hacked, go out of business, or become insolvent, which could lead to the loss of your funds.
On the other hand, non-custodial wallets, also known as self-custodied or private key wallets, offer the advantage of giving you full control of your private keys. This means that you are responsible for the safekeeping of your private keys, which can be safeguarded using techniques such as se